Nobody wants to find out a poop bag was too thin while it is still in their hand. Thickness, size, and how easily the bag opens and ties matter more than most people expect, especially if you walk a big dog or pick up in wet weather.
We compared five popular options from the listings and focused on bag size, how they are packed, and the honest trade-offs. If you are still deciding what else you need for walks and the yard, start with our complete buying guide to dog potty and waste supplies.
Affiliate Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, PurrYork Pets earns from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
1. Earth Rated Dog Poop Bags on Refill Rolls, Unscented: Best Overall
Price Range: Under $15
This is the roll most dog owners have seen at some point. The listing offers 270 unscented bags on refill rolls, each about 13 inches long and 9 inches wide. The maker describes the bags as extra thick and leak-proof, each one tears along a built-in line, and a “3 bags left” sticker warns you before you run out. The listing also notes recycled plastic and shows a very large review base with a 4.8 star average.

What we like
- Very large number of ratings, with a high average
- Roomy 13 by 9 inch size for most dogs
- Easy tear line and a low-supply reminder
- Several pack sizes and scents to pick from
Watch out for
- Rolls need a dispenser or holder to be convenient on walks
- Recycled plastic is not the same as compostable
- The rating covers several scents and pack sizes, so check the exact version you choose
Best for: Owners who want a proven, no-fuss everyday roll.
2. Pogi’s Large Dog Poop Bags with Handles, Unscented: Best With Easy-Tie Handles
Price Range: Under $20
These are 300 flat-packed bags in a dispensing box rather than on rolls. Each bag is about 7 by 14.5 inches, and the built-in tie handles let you knot the bag closed without wrestling the opening. The listing describes the bags as extra thick, leak-proof, and odor-sealing. It holds a 4.6 star average from well over ten thousand ratings.

What we like
- Tie handles make closing the bag quick
- Roomy length suits larger dogs
- Pull-out box keeps bags neat and easy to grab
- Strong rating from a large number of buyers
Watch out for
- Not on rolls, so they will not load into a standard roll dispenser
- Narrower than the 9 inch bags in this list
- Check the listing to pick scented or unscented
Best for: Owners of bigger dogs who prefer handles to knotting.
3. Bags on Board Dog Poop Bags, 315 Count: Best Extra-Roomy Bag
Price Range: Under $25
This box holds 315 bags in assorted colors, each about 9 by 14 inches. The listing says the bags are leak-proof and tear apart easily, and that the rolls fit most dispensers. The packaging is a compact box that is easy to store and pull from. It holds a 4.8 star average from several thousand ratings.

What we like
- Larger 9 by 14 inch bag size
- High rating from several thousand buyers
- Space-saving box that stores easily
- Listing says rolls fit most dispensers
Watch out for
- Costs more per bag than many bulk roll packs, based on the listing price
- Colors are assorted, so you cannot choose one
- Pack options and prices change often, so check the count when you order
Best for: Anyone who wants a bigger bag than the standard size.
4. Arm & Hammer Easy Tear Dog and Cat Waste Bags, 180 Count: Best for Odor Control
Price Range: Under $15
These 180 bags measure about 9 by 14 inches and are made with activated baking soda to help reduce odors, according to the listing. The maker says each bag is twice as thick as a grocery bag and describes them as easy to tear and heavy duty. They can also be used for cat litter and other small messes. The listing shows a 4.6 star average and Amazon’s Choice badge.

What we like
- Baking soda is meant to help with odor
- Easy-tear design
- Can double as cat litter or diaper bags
- Large 9 by 14 inch size
Watch out for
- Scented, which some owners and dogs may not like
- Smaller count than bulk packs, so it runs out sooner
- Thickness is compared with grocery bags, not rated as a leak guarantee
Best for: Walkers who want some odor help on short outings and at home.
5. Doggy Do Good Dog Poop Bags, Unscented, 360 Count: Best Recycled-Content Pick
Price Range: Under $40
This 360-bag box holds standard-size bags of about 7 by 13.4 inches with expanding sides for extra room. The listing says they are 18 microns thick, unscented, and made with 50 percent recycled plastic and 15 percent biobased material. They are meant to fit most leash dispensers. The listing shows a 4.6 star average from over fourteen thousand ratings.

What we like
- Recycled and biobased content listed
- Stated thickness of 18 microns
- Expanding sides add room
- Unscented and easy to open per the listing
Watch out for
- One of the pricier options per bag
- About 7 inches wide, narrower than some competitors
- The landfill breakdown claim is the maker’s, so treat it as a claim and not a guarantee
Best for: Shoppers who want recycled content without switching bag types.
How to Choose
Start with size. A 9 by 13 or 9 by 14 inch bag gives most dogs enough room to tie, while 7 inch bags can work if the length is generous. Check how the bags are packed next: rolls fit leash dispensers (see our guide to leash poop bag holders), while flat boxes and bags with handles usually do not.
Then think about scent and volume. Unscented bags are the safe default; scented ones add a fragrance that some people love and others skip. If you walk more than one dog or go through bags quickly, a larger roll count saves reorders, and our bulk dog poop bag picks cover that need. If you want plant-based or certified compostable bags instead, read our guide to biodegradable and compostable dog poop bags.
FAQ
Are thicker bags always better?
Usually thicker bags resist tearing and leaks, but size and how well the bag opens matter too. A thick bag that is hard to open is still frustrating on a rainy walk.
What size poop bag do I need?
Most dogs do fine with a bag around 9 by 13 inches. Large breeds may prefer a bit more length, and the bags in this list range from roughly 7 to 9 inches wide.
Will bags with handles fit a leash dispenser?
Handle bags in a flat box usually will not load into a roll dispenser. If you want handles, plan to carry a few in a pouch or pocket.
Are leak-proof bags the same as compostable bags?
No. Leak-proof describes how the bag is built, not how it breaks down. Check the listing for any compost or biobased certification and your local rules for pet waste.
Can I use dog poop bags for cat litter?
Some listings say they work for cat litter and small household messes. Check each listing, since not every maker makes that claim.
Final Thoughts
The best poop bag is the one that opens easily, holds up, and fits your dog and your dispenser. For most people the Earth Rated roll is the easy first pick, while handles, bigger sizes, or recycled content can tip the choice if those matter to you. For a full overview of what to buy next, read our complete buying guide to dog potty and waste supplies.
Related posts: bulk dog poop bags for multi-dog homes, dog poop bag holders for leash, and dog poop trash cans for outside.

4 thoughts on “Top 5 Best Extra Thick Leak-Proof Dog Poop Bags”