Puzzle toys make your cat think. Treat puzzles slow down eating and add a challenge, while puzzle boxes combine balls, teasers and scratching.
These five range from level 2 to level 3 puzzles and two wooden scratch boxes. Check with your vet about treat amounts. For more types, see our complete cat toy buying guide.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. This does not change the price you pay. Prices change often, so check the current price on Amazon.
1. Catstages Nina Ottosson Buggin’ Out Puzzle: Most Popular Pick
Price Range: $10 to $20
A 14-inch level 2 puzzle with 16 hidden treat cups, described as a slow feeder. It has an Amazon’s Choice badge and more than 5K bought in the past month.

What we like
- 16 treat cups
- Intermediate level
- Slow-feeding design, per the listing
- Many recent purchases
Watch out for
- Needs treats or kibble
- Not for cats that ignore food
- Check the listing for materials
Best for: Food-motivated cats.
2. Catstages Nina Ottosson Rainy Day Puzzle: Best Advanced Puzzle
Price Range: $15 to $25
A 14-inch level 3 advanced puzzle with 19 hidden treat cups. It has an Amazon’s Choice badge and more than 2K bought in the past month.

What we like
- Advanced level for clever cats
- 19 cups
- Slow feeder, per the listing
- Good for problem solving
Watch out for
- May frustrate beginners
- Needs treats
- Costs more than the level 2 puzzle
Best for: Cats that have mastered easier puzzles.
3. Catstages Nina Ottosson Kitty Cube: Best Budget Puzzle
Price Range: Under $15
An 8.7-inch level 2 puzzle with 10 hidden treat cups, sold and shipped by Amazon in the data. It has an Amazon’s Choice badge and more than 600 bought in the past month.

What we like
- Low price
- Compact
- Intermediate level
- Shipped by Amazon
Watch out for
- Fewer cups than larger puzzles
- Smaller sales history
- Needs treats
Best for: Small spaces and first-time puzzle users.
4. Cat Scratch Puzzle Enrichment Box: Best for Scratchers
Price Range: $30 to $40
A box with a built-in nail-file scratcher, three balls and two wands. It is 15.75 by 12.2 inches in the large size and has more than 2K bought in the past month.

What we like
- Combines scratching and play
- Balls and teasers included
- Large and small sizes
- Many recent purchases
Watch out for
- Highest price
- Sandpaper-style surface, check the listing
- Not a replacement for nail trims
Best for: Cats that scratch and bat at balls.
5. Large Cat Nail File Box Puzzle: Best Wooden Puzzle Box
Price Range: $25 to $35
A wooden pull-out box with sandpaper, three balls and two teasers. No assembly is required. It has more than 2K bought in the past month.

What we like
- No assembly
- Sturdy wood, per the listing
- Large and small sizes
- Includes balls and teasers
Watch out for
- Check the listing for sizes
- Sandpaper wears
- Similar in design to the other scratch box in this list
Best for: Cats that like to paw and scratch.
How to Choose
Match difficulty to your cat. Start at level 2 or below. Use a small portion of your cat’s usual food and count it toward the daily total. Ask your vet about treats. For a cat that loves balls, try our ball track cat toys. For hands-on play, see our wand toys.
FAQ
Do puzzles help with boredom?
They add mental stimulation, but results vary.
What do I put in them?
Treats or dry food, per the listings. Ask your vet.
Will my cat get frustrated?
Start easy.
Are scratch boxes safe?
Check for rough edges.
How do I clean?
Wipe with a damp cloth.
Final Thoughts
The level 2 Buggin’ Out puzzle is the most popular and a good start. The Rainy Day suits advanced cats, and the scratch boxes are for cats that like to claw.
For more, read our complete cat toy buying guide or see our automatic cat toys.
